The Hidden Cost of Broken Performance Reviews - And How to Fix Them

Performance reviews should be a powerful tool for growth, but for many organisations, they have become a source of frustration.

Instead of inspiring teams and fuelling development, outdated review processes often feel like a mere formality. Managers scramble to recall events from six months ago, employees dread the awkward conversations, and meaningful progress falls by the wayside.

In a working world where skills gaps are widening, hybrid work is the norm, and employee expectations are rising, businesses cannot afford to rely on broken systems. According to a recent Gartner study, only 14% of employees strongly agree that their annual performance reviews inspire them to improve — a sobering statistic that highlights the urgent need for change.

This blog explores the hidden costs of broken performance management and shows how embracing continuous feedback, powered by solutions like Myrus, can transform both employee satisfaction and business success.

The Real Costs of Broken Review Processes

Outdated and ineffective performance reviews are not just a minor inconvenience — they come with significant hidden costs that affect every layer of an organisation.

1. Employee Disengagement

When performance conversations happen too infrequently, employees often feel invisible. According to Gallup’s 2024 Workplace Report, employees who receive little feedback are twice as likely to be disengaged. Without regular recognition or developmental guidance, motivation and morale suffer, eroding the very foundation of team success.

2. Missed Opportunities for Growth

Traditional annual reviews typically focus on retrospective critique rather than proactive development. This results in missed chances to close skill gaps early, nurture leadership potential, and align personal ambitions with organisational goals. Research by LinkedIn’s Learning Trends report shows that employees prioritise development opportunities when choosing where to work — organisations clinging to outdated reviews risk losing their top talent.

3. Increased Turnover and Recruitment Costs

The link between poor performance management and employee attrition is well-established. Replacing a single employee can cost up to £30,000 in the UK once recruitment, onboarding, and lost productivity are factored in (Oxford Economics, 2024). When reviews are poorly executed, good people leave, and the cost hits hard.

4. Operational Inefficiency

Without real-time insights into team performance, managers make decisions based on outdated or incomplete information. This not only slows down strategic execution but also creates silos where feedback is hoarded until it is too late to act. In fast-moving industries, operational agility is essential, and lagging feedback loops are a serious liability.

Why Traditional Annual Reviews Fail

The traditional model of the annual review is no longer fit for purpose. In today's fast-paced and increasingly remote work environment, waiting six or twelve months to address employee performance is simply too slow — and too shallow.

1. Delayed Feedback Means Delayed Action

When feedback is given months after the event, it loses its relevance and impact. Small issues become major frustrations, while opportunities for praise go unacknowledged. As a result, employees are left guessing about their performance, with engagement levels dropping dramatically over time.

2. Lack of Context and Meaning

Traditional reviews often feel like they focus more on ticking boxes than truly understanding an individual’s achievements and challenges. With only a snapshot of information available, managers may overlook the daily contributions and struggles that define real performance. In a hybrid work model where visibility is reduced, this blind spot grows even larger.

3. One-Size-Fits-All Evaluation

Annual reviews typically force employees into rigid categories, applying identical KPIs across varied roles and circumstances. This standardised approach fails to acknowledge individual growth, learning styles, and career aspirations — all of which are now major priorities for today’s workforce, especially among Millennials and Gen Z employees.

4. The Trust Erosion Effect

When employees perceive reviews as unfair, outdated, or irrelevant, trust in management erodes. Studies from CIPD (2024) show that organisations with low trust levels experience 40% higher employee turnover. An outdated review process is not just inefficient — it is actively damaging to your culture.

Modern performance management must evolve to meet new expectations: timely, personalised, and embedded into everyday work.

How Continuous Performance Management Changes Everything

Continuous performance management is not just a trend — it is rapidly becoming the gold standard for future-focused organisations. By shifting from retrospective annual appraisals to real-time, ongoing development, businesses unlock a new level of agility, engagement, and excellence.

1. Real-Time Goal Tracking

Rather than setting static goals that are forgotten after the first quarter, continuous performance management enables dynamic goal tracking. Employees and managers can see progress in real time, adjusting objectives as priorities shift. This creates alignment across teams and ensures that work remains relevant and impactful.

2. Frequent, Natural Feedback Conversations

Feedback should not be a formal, anxiety-inducing event — it should be part of everyday working life. Regular, informal feedback promotes learning, celebrates wins as they happen, and addresses challenges early. According to a McKinsey report (2024), companies that cultivate continuous feedback cultures see 30% higher employee engagement.

3. Proactive Development Planning

By keeping a constant pulse on employee growth, managers can spot training needs, ambition signals, and potential career paths long before formal reviews. This proactive development keeps employees motivated and significantly reduces the risk of stagnation or flight risk.

4. Building Trust and Transparency

Continuous conversations foster genuine relationships between managers and their teams. Employees feel seen, supported, and valued. This transparency builds organisational trust, leading to stronger collaboration, innovation, and overall resilience.

Continuous performance management isn’t just a better process — it is a culture shift. It treats employees as active partners in their own success, not passive recipients of sporadic feedback.

Myrus – Empowering Managers Without the Overload

In a world where managers are stretched thin, the solution is not to add more complexity — it is to provide tools that make their working lives simpler, smarter, and more impactful. That is exactly what Myrus delivers.

One Platform for All Managers' Needs

Myrus streamlines performance management by consolidating live goal tracking, continuous feedback, targeted development planning, and rapid reporting into a single intuitive platform. Managers no longer need to juggle spreadsheets, emails, and disjointed HR systems — everything they need is in one place, accessible at any time.

Simple, Accessible, Seamless

Built with real managers in mind (not just IT experts), Myrus is refreshingly simple to use. The platform integrates smoothly into existing workflows without the need for extensive training or disruptive system overhauls. Whether managing teams on-site or remotely, managers have secure, instant access to the tools they need.

Results That Speak for Themselves

Organisations using Myrus report higher employee engagement, stronger team alignment, and lower turnover rates. By giving managers clarity, confidence, and real-time insights, businesses can finally move from reactive performance management to a culture of proactive leadership and sustained excellence.

Support Managers to Support Your People

When you empower your managers with the right tools, you empower your whole organisation. Myrus is not just another app — it is a hand extended to your managers, helping them lead better, not work harder.

Ready to see it in action?

📥 Download ‘Empower Managers – The Myrus Approach’

Download Document

Book a free demo today.

Book a demo